CAF alternative

Legacy vs CAF Charity Account

The Charities Aid Foundation's Charity Account lets you pay into a balance, have Gift Aid added to it, and donate to almost any charity when you choose. Legacy is a non-profit giving app for backing UK causes, with one monthly budget split across as many charities as you like.

If you used CAF vouchers or a CharityCard, they've gone: CAF discontinued them in May 2026, and its account fees now carry VAT. Both are good homes for regular giving. The real difference is who you want to give to and how you want to manage it. Here's an honest side by side.

Which one suits you

Choose CAF Charity Account if

A flexible account for any charity

  • You want to donate to almost any charity, including ones overseas, which CAF checks first.
  • You'd rather pay into a balance and decide later when and where each donation goes.
  • You give over £200,000 a year, where CAF's fee drops below 4%.
  • You'd like to sort things out by phone as well as online.

Choose Legacy if

Built for regular giving to UK causes

  • You want to back causes across health, animals, climate, poverty and more, all in one place.
  • You'd rather set one monthly budget and have it split automatically, with no balance to manage.
  • You want to see what your charities achieve, through a positive news feed and an impact tracker.
  • You want your contact details kept off charity marketing lists by default.

Side by side

What each one offers individual donors in the UK, from their own websites.

Who runs it
Legacy
UK non-profit, Social Enterprise UK accredited
CAF Charity Account
Registered charity (no. 268369)
Focus
Legacy
Any UK cause
CAF Charity Account
Any charity, in the UK or overseas
Who you can give to
Legacy
13,000+ UK charities
CAF Charity Account
160,000+ charities, checked by CAF
How it works
Legacy
One monthly budget, split automatically
CAF Charity Account
Pay into an account, then choose when and where to donate
Ways to pay
Legacy
Direct Debit
CAF Charity Account
Direct Debit, card or PayPal top-ups
Cost
Legacy
3.75% third-party costs on the donation, optional tip
CAF Charity Account
4% plus VAT on money paid in, Gift Aid included, on the first £200,000 a year
Gift Aid
Legacy
Claimed by Charities Trust, less a 4% fee
CAF Charity Account
25% added to your account when CAF claims it
Minimum
Legacy
£10 a month
CAF Charity Account
£10 a month by Direct Debit, or £100 one-off to open
Impact and news
Legacy
Impact items for your share, plus a good-news feed
CAF Charity Account
Donation history in your online account
Change or pause
Legacy
Change, skip or pause anytime in the app
CAF Charity Account
Change arrangements in your online account
Your contact details
Legacy
Kept from charities unless you opt in
CAF Charity Account
Anonymous option removes your name from a donation
Tax summary
Legacy
HMRC-friendly PDF in the app
CAF Charity Account
Statements in your online account
How you manage it
Legacy
iOS and Android
CAF Charity Account
Online account and phone, no app

CAF details from cafonline.org and its fee schedule, checked November 2026. CAF's fee falls in bands above £200,000 a year, counted from May to April. CAF also handles share gifts and overseas donations, which Legacy doesn't.

Where £20 a month lands

A £20 monthly donation from a UK taxpayer, with Gift Aid, before any optional tip. The bar is out of £25, what the charity would get if nothing came off at all.

CAF Charity Account£23.80

£20 plus £5 Gift Aid, less 4% plus VAT of £1.20.

Legacy£23.87

£19.25 after 3.75% third-party costs, plus £4.62 Gift Aid.

At £20 a month the two are within 7p of each other. CAF's fee covers everything paid in, Gift Aid included. On Legacy, 3.75% comes off your donation and Charities Trust keeps 4% of the Gift Aid it claims. None of that is ours: it covers Stripe, which collects your Direct Debit, and Charities Trust, which pays your charities and claims Gift Aid. Legacy runs on optional tips instead.

What your donation pays for

On Legacy, every pound becomes something you can picture. These are real impact items from charities on the app, at the prices the app shows, and your giving counts them up as it lands. See how the tracker works.

  • A researcher in gloves and a mask looking through a microscope in a lab

    £2

    British Heart Foundation

    Supply microscope research materials

    Materials for BHF researchers to study faulty heart cells under the microscope.

  • A smiling nurse in scrubs and a stethoscope holding a paper heart

    £20

    British Heart Foundation

    Give one hour of nursing

    An hour of a cardiac nurse on the Heart Helpline, there when callers need it most.

  • Five puffins standing on dark coastal rocks

    £30

    RSPB

    Protect seas for puffins

    Work that keeps sandeels plentiful, so breeding puffins can feed their chicks.

  • A researcher taking notes while talking with a participant

    £50

    Mental Health Foundation

    Advance mental health research

    Research that strengthens prevention and support, and helps protect lives.

What you get with Legacy

  • No balance

    Your budget goes straight out

    There's no account to top up and nothing waiting to be given away. Set one monthly budget and Legacy splits it between your charities for you.

  • Your impact

    See what your giving does

    Impact items turn your share into things you can picture, like an hour of a heart nurse's time. A good-news feed brings stories from the charities you back, not fundraising appeals.

    How the tracker works
  • Full control

    Change it from your phone

    Adjust your budget, add a cause, skip a month or pause the lot in the app. No phone calls and no cancellation period.

  • Every penny

    A receipt for every payment

    Each payment shows what every charity received, the Gift Aid added and the costs. Filter to any UK tax year, and your yearly tax summary is a tap away.

So, what is Legacy?

The UK's first non-profit giving app. Pick the causes you care about, set one monthly budget, and Legacy splits it between them. One Direct Debit covers the lot.

From £10 a month. Pause or update anytime.